Making Charcoal-Part Three

Rethinking what I know

There has been a lot of water under the bridge since I last wrote about charcoal in April. In my initial test I thought I was getting good charcoal from my little retort at 720c. I even made the comment that that it burned with a nice small blue flame.

Well, a small blue flame is not what we need. We need a honkin’ big flame! Over the summer as I read about Japanese forging and Tatara I came across an article that talked about charcoal for forging and smelting.

There it was in black and white. Forging charcoal must keep a good portion of the volatiles to add power to the burn. Smelting charcoal needs even more.

Those few words sounded the death knell for making charcoal in a self fueling retort.

Your ads will be inserted here by

Easy AdSense.

Please go to the plugin admin page to
Paste your ad code OR
Suppress this ad slot.

Letting Go

That was a hard one to accept. After all it is just so cool,  cooking the wood with its own gases. And then there was the ego thing. I didn’t come up with the idea of using the wood gases to self cook but I did devise a simple system to utilize it.
Over the last 10 years or so I have heard from people around the world who have used it. In my search for more charcoal info, time an time again I would run across sites that referred to my system. Sometimes giving me attribution sometimes not.

Don’t get me wrong-if you are looking to make biochar then it works great. You are only looking for carbon to add to soil. If it is soft and crumbly and easy to pulverize, so much the better.

Metallurgical Grade

We need charcoal with some backbone, with fire in its heart. Charcoal that has just stopped being wood, with a glass like sheen and the power to change the shape of steel. So began the search for the perfect charcoal and a way to make it.

The picture above is just such charcoal and I made it this week. It is not the perfect charcoal but we are getting close.

Stay Tuned.

32 Responses to “Making Charcoal-Part Three”

  1. Russell says:

    I read your thoughts on charcoal, and had a few ideas….
    Green wood has differing properties than dried. Kiln dried have differing properties then air dried. Could the source material have been processed after drying?

    Another idea was quenching the charcoal at a certain point and allowing it to dry again? It seems to me from my experience with campfires that the charcoal that went "tink" was from a dowsed fire.

    The amazing thing that I read about charcoal, from an ASU alumni brochure. That in Thailand where the water is so contaminated, and yet there is charcoal available on the streets. Nice oil-sheen colored charcoal, that a fist sized chunk will remove pesticides, and benzine from a 5-gal pail. Bacteria is another matter though.

  2. SteveR says:

    Dan, wonderful website, I’ve been at work on a charcoal cupola and have made charcoal by several methods in the past — not your barrel retort (yet) but was aware of it from seeing the early one many years ago on the net.

    One thing I wanted to bring up in relation to smelting with charcoal — in the US in the 19th century in furnaces of about 6 tons output/day was that they seem to have used a two stage process with two types of charcoal. There was the initial cooking of the ore using brands (or partially coaled wood) in a separate furnace, and then second using that partially refined ore broken up into small pieces with the fully coaled charcoal in the main furnace.

    So in effect, you are possibly doing the same thing in a single stage by trying to make charcoal that is nearly but not fully carbonized. I do wonder whether a two stage process might be workable for you, or whether combining brands with fully coaled charcoal would give you similar results to the ideal coal you seek?

    The two grades of charcoal were culled from the same rick style burn in traditional US practice. The pile never burned completely uniformly for charcoal burners.

    I do wonder about our need to produce perfect repeatable uniformity, rather than adapt to the nature of a charcoal burn. Working with the personality of what is made available. What do you think?

    • Dan O'Connor says:

      Hi Steve,
      Thanks for a great comment.Pre-cooking or “roasting” of the ore is a standard practice. It gets rid of a lot of impurities such as sulfur and makes it much easier to break up. Having said that the Japanese harvested iron bearing sand from the mountains and concentrated it by running though a big sluice to float out the lighter material leaving the heavier iron sand.They did not roast this iron source which was primarily magnetite. My source is rocks of ore so will roast at least some of it to see the results.

  3. SteveR says:

    Fascinating to me about the black sand. That is what is examined, and then discarded in searching for gold. Ironic.
    Or of iron.
    Ore of iron.
    Alchemy. The transformation is in the comprehension. Not the substance.
    They had it.

  4. porn 17 says:

    hi, I need the replacement boa for mx 175 (which model is it?) how can I do to buy it?
    finest regards Alberto

    my site; porn 17

  5. Elizabeth Deckert says:

    I must salute your work as these type of work will definitely of use and will help in thesis type work too if you want people salute you on your essay writing you can try ,this will better your essay writing, The amazing fact about charcoal, That in Thailand where the water is so contaminated, and yet there is charcoal available on streets

  6. – most affordable top-notch private proxies with 50% discount! Top-notch quality, Unlimited proxies, Excellent speed along with Least expensive costs — just $0.25 for each proxy! Best private proxies only by

  7. Ella Warlow says:

    I liked your articles on charcoal but then you stopped writing about. So it is good to see you back with charcoal. The article can be good if you use research paper by ninjaessays because they check it for grammatical mistakes. If the charcoal quality is good you will see the flame would be nice also with the right color of blue in it.

  8. say thanks to a lot for your internet site it aids a great deal.|

  9. csgo weapon says:

    Keep up the incredible work !! Lovin’ it!

  10. buy csgo says:

    Basically desired to point out Now i’m glad that i happened on the webpage!.

  11. This is a truly super post. Must concede that you are in the midst of the best author I have perused. I welcome your trying to talk about this class of article.

  12. Enable educational corporations impose computer software works seeing that often considerable or essential inside their admissions exercise. The inadequately executed essay or dissertation or dissertation could potentially cause some sort of stellar college student for getting declined. In spite of this, excellent computer software works may also help pupils as well as minimal rankings wind up in this colleges inside their desires.

  13. vet clinic says:

    That Conference is annihilation potentially. Any ideal pieces allow information about it. The issue is peculiar occurrence that once in a while plentiful distils are talking keenly about. I bear examine yet identified with various my pals.

  14. That is the right net website for all of us who desires to apprehend approximately this difficulty rely. The submit can be very stunning and it’s notable to have a look at. i have recognized very essential by using the usage of this publish. I understand the valuable recommendation you're making to be had for your expertly written content. I need to thank you for this form of informative article. I definitely recognize.

  15. With havin so much written content do you ever run into any problems of plagorism or copyright infringement?

    My website has a lot of completely unique content I’ve either authored myself or outsourced but it looks like
    a lot of it is popping it up all over the
    internet without my authorization. Do you know any methods to help
    prevent content from being ripped off? I’d truly appreciate it.

  16. The people you love are lucky to have you in their lives. Your site has a certian aura about it. I shared this on my website and 16 of my friends have already seen it!

  17. dispensaries says:

    I actually felt my brain growing when I read your blog. I am hoping you write once more very soon!

  18. I will bookmark this article. Try to make the guest blog as amazing as possible by promoting and dropping links.

  19. Sheldon Owen says:

    Just wanted to say fantastic write up! Such a deep answer! You have opened my eyes to varying views on this topic with interesting and solid content. You has some interesting and great content. You really sparked my interest.

  20. Sheldon Owen says:

    Keep up the excellent quality writing, it is rare to see a nice blog like this one these days. I will bookmark this posts. good work, keep it up. Extremely good short blog. That cleared it up for me.

  21. You should be thanked more often. You have brought up a very superb points You are absolutly a pro.

  22. Sheldon Owen says:

    I actually felt my brain growing when I browsed your blog. I bet you sweat glitter. You always know just what to say. It is like you wrote the book on it or something.

  23. I never discovered any attention-grabbing post like yours. good work, keep it up. Your creative potential seems limitless. I feel like people should send you cash for this great content.

  24. My brother recommended I may like this web site. He was totally
    right. This publish actually made my day. You cann’t consider just how so much time I had spent for this info!


  25. hello!,I love your writing so much! share we keep in touch extra about your article on AOL?
    I require a specialist on this space to unravel my problem.
    Maybe that is you! Looking ahead to see you.

  26. Herbert Poller says:

    Thank you for your effort, real interesting read.

  27. voyancepascher says:

    nice post. I have been wondering about this topic, so thanks for sharing. I will certainly be subscribing to your blog.

  28. shz khatri says:

    As always your articles do inspire me. Every single detail you have posted was great.Why Men Pull Away Review

  29. bank login says:

    Enroll online today to manage your bank accounts, pay your bills, transfer funds and more with bbcpak Online Banking Instruction.

  30. ocean of games says:

    joyful I had the danger.You can get more details about ocean of games from our website.ocean of games

  31. Daletec says:

    Flame retardants are chemicals that are added or applied to fire resistant material in order to slow or prevent the start/growth of fire.

Leave a Reply